Summary
- Denis Villeneuve’s
Dune
adaptation successfully translates Herbert’s intricate world, engaging audiences with stunning visuals and action sequences. - Lynch’s 1984
Dune
failed due to poor construction, unconvincing effects, and lack of understanding of the source material, leading to negative reviews. - Bad timing, shallow commercial motives, and poor marketing contributed to the 1984
Dune
‘s failure at the box office, contrasting with Villeneuve’s successful adaptation.
The biggest challenge for any screen adaptation of Frank Herbert’s epic 1965 science-fiction novel Dune is how to distill the intricate, vast ecology of Arrakis, the desert planet where much of the novel’s story takes place, into a clear visual form that’s compelling and relatable to audiences, especially those who haven’t read Herbert’s mammoth novel.
While the novel covers this through a detailed appendices section, any screen adaptation is invariably left to present this information through cumbersome exposition scenes. However, Dune and Dune: Part Two director Denis Villeneuve has proved he can pull off the adaptation and translate the novel’s richly detailed world visually without becoming bogged down in endless narrative.
Moreover, by covering the entirety of the novel in two films, Villeneuve drastically increased audience engagement with the film’s spectacular action sequences and visuals. While Villeneuve’s adaptations certainly require close attention from audiences, Dune left audiences clamoring for the sequel, which has received some of the best reviews of any film in recent history.
Villeneuve’s impressive achievement stands in stark contrast to the dismal failure of the first film, David Lynch’s Dune, which, upon its 1984 release, gained a reputation for being one of the worst films of its era and inspired the pessimistic belief that Herbert’s novel was untranslatable, especially within a single film.
David Lynch Was a Bad Choice to Direct Dune
Dune (1984)
- Release Date
- December 14, 1984
- Runtime
- 2hr 17min
In 1981, producer Dino De Laurentiis hired director David Lynch to helm the first feature film adaptation of Frank Herbert’s novel Dune, based on Lynch’s acclaimed 1980 biographical drama film The Elephant Man, which received eight Academy Award nominations, including Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Director nominations for Lynch.
Lynch was preceded by Ridley Scott, who abandoned the film to direct Blade Runner. Moreover, Lynch became attached to Dune after refusing the opportunity to direct Return of the Jedi, despite the fact that Lynch was initially unfamiliar with Herbert’s novel before being contacted by De Laurentiis. After subsequently becoming enthralled with the story, Lynch agreed to both direct the film adaptation and write the screenplay.
Lynch, like Scott before him, initially conceived of turning Herbert’s novel into two films. Of course, the entire novel ended up being condensed into a single 137-minute film, which resulted in bitter feelings for Lynch, who was denied final cut privileges with Dune and subsequently disowned the film.
How Dune 2 Completely Subverts the Chosen One Storyline
The chosen one is one of the most widely recognizable staples of genre fiction. Dune: Part Two takes an axe to the very concept of it.
Lynch’s idiosyncratic sensibilities were at odds with the source material from the moment of his hiring. Through Lynch’s muddled screenplay, 1984 Dune became less a faithful representation of Herbert’s novel and more a reflection of Lynch’s twisted vision of the future. While this approach could have made for a fascinating film outside the Dune universe, the truncated film fails to capture the essence of Herbert’s novel.
Lynch’s Dune Is a Convoluted and Sloppy Mess
The most basic flaw of Lynch’s film is related to its basic construction, in terms of the illogical decision to try to fit the entirety of the Dune novel into a 137-minute theatrical cut. In comparison, Denis Villeneuve’s first adaptation, which encompasses approximately half of the book, has a running time of 155 minutes, while Dune: Part Two has a running time of 165 minutes.
The 1984 Dune contains a plot that is virtually incomprehensible to even the most dedicated students of the novel. Little clarity is provided through the film’s various plodding internal monologue and voice-over scenes, which ostensibly exist for characters to project their thoughts but practically serve to weaken the audience’s engagement with the film.
10 Best Movies Like Dune to Watch Next
From Interstellar to Blade Runner 2049, here are exceptional and visually stunning films like Dune that we recommend watching next.
The 1984 Dune is visually unappealing. The exterior scenes appear dusty, murky, and sometimes unintelligible, while the interior scenes are superficially pristine, giving the film a cold, hollow feel. Moreover, despite a then sizable budget of approximately $40 million, many of the effects in the movie look cheap and unconvincing.
This includes the much-anticipated sandworm sequence, in which the creatures are initially fearsome and impressive in appearance but lack a realistic sense of depth and dimension upon closer inspection. Indeed, in most of the desert scenes, the characters, instead of beholding a scene of awe and wonder, often look like they’re staring into a void that’s been filled with cheesy visual effects work.
The 1984 Dune Was Poorly Distributed and Marketed
David Lynch’s Dune was released amid the 1984 holiday box-office season, dominated by the hit buddy cop action comedy film Beverly Hills Cop. In its opening weekend of domestic release, Dune grossed approximately $6 million and finished in second place behind Beverly Hills Cop, which was then playing in 1,532 theaters, while Dune debuted in just 915 theaters.
Throughout its domestic theatrical run, in which Lynch’s film grossed approximately $30.9 million, Dune never played in more than 975 theaters. In contrast, the 2021 adaptation, which grossed nearly $435 million at the worldwide box office, opened domestically in 4,125 theaters.
In 1984, Dune was a victim of bad timing, particularly in terms of its proximity to the recently ended original Star Wars trilogy. While the original Star Wars trilogy certainly had an overhanging effect on virtually every science-fiction film of the 1980s, this was especially present with Dune, originally intended to be “Star Wars for grown-ups,” with expected sequels from David Lynch.
Indeed, in contrast to the obvious love and understanding of the source material that Denis Villeneuve brought to the franchise, the making of 1984 Dune was dictated by cynical, shallow commercial motives. The primary thinking in 1984 seemed to be that if only fans of the novel went to see the film, it would be a blockbuster success. This obviously didn’t happen. The 1984 adaptation of Dune is streaming on Max, along with Denis Villeneuve’s 2021 film. Dune: Part Two is playing in theaters now.
